The Case for European Citizenship? Transnational Market Citizens in the European Union
Nora Siklodi, Royal Holloway, University of London
This paper explores a market-based approach to understanding European Union (EU) citizenship and demonstrates how migration within an integrated regional market affects migrants' citizenship practices and behaviours. It is often argued that the dynamics of globalisation have subordinated the state and politics at the transnational level to economic considerations and regional markets (Mittelman, 2000; Talani, 2010). It has even been suggested that the same dynamics have created a model, which is largely economic in nature (Everson, 1995). This paper uses the concept of 'market citizenship' to shed light on EU citizenship, the only example of regional citizenship in the world today. The extent literature on EU citizenship (Bellamy, 2008; 2011) tends to describe this status as merely 'pie in the sky' (D'Oliveira, 1995). Yet, survey data suggest that the status of EU citizenship has substantial meaning for a sizeable minority of the EU's population (Eurobarometer, 2010). The paper sheds both conceptual and empirical light on transnational market citizenship in the EU. It first examines the multi-level aspects of EU citizenshipquot;embracing both transnational and national levelsquot;and how this interacts with personal experiences and other factors (e.g. gender, education, age, etc.) (Yuval-Davis, 2010). For the analysis of national citizenship, the paper employs Bellamy's (2008) definition and EU citizenship is defined as a composite of various elements, including mobility, tolerance, new forms of political action and cognitive sophistication (Ingelhart, 1970). The paper then explores the actual experiences of young (aged 18-35) migrant EU citizens, the group for whom market citizenship is likely to have the most meaning, through an analysis of focus-group material collected in Sweden and Britain and quantitative evidence from EU-wide surveys (Eurobarometer and European Social Survey).