View All

Altered Gravities: Ireland, Brexit and Structural Power

Patrick Holden

Brexit will readjust the complex power relations between the Irish and UK governments and the EU institutions. The EU is considered a locus of 'structural power' because its collective economic weight, and legal-institutional pre-eminence, allows it to shape member states and external neighbours in many respects. This understanding informs the mainstream view that Brexit will leave the UK in a weaker position. On the other hand, independent Ireland spent 5 decades firmly in the socio-economic and financial orbit of the UK, and even in recent decades the relationship with its larger neighbour remains highly asymmetric. This asymmetry was masked by EU membership and a close partnership on Northern Ireland but will re-emerge in the Brexit process. Accordingly Ireland's situation is sharply bifurcated between its role as a part of the larger entity and its role as smaller neighbour. The paper analyses the material interdependence and power-relations before focusing on a discourse analysis of how Irish (in particular) and British elites construct power and interdependence in their positions on Brexit. This study will combine a content analysis as well as a more qualitative discourse analysis. Finally the paper traces the major lines of tension and likely future scenarios for UK-Irish relations.



The abstracts and papers on this website reflect the views and opinions of the author(s). UACES cannot be held responsible for the opinions of others. Conference papers are works-in-progress - they should not be cited without the author's permission.