Home > Conferences and Events > Previous Events > Events 2002 > Belfast 2002 > Abstracts
The Future of Europe:
UACES 32nd Annual Conference and 7th Research Conference
Queen's University Belfast, Monday 2nd to Wednesday
4th September 2002
Abstracts of papers to be presented at the Research sessions of the conference can be found below. The conference also includes Plenary sessions with invited speakers.
The abstracts on this page are in alphabetical order by
surname.
1) If you know the name of the author, use the A-Z key below to find the abstract
you are interested in.
2) If not, scroll down to where the panels are listed and you can
browse through their titles.
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
To print a single abstract from this page, highlight the selected text with your mouse (left-click and drag). From the Menu bar, select File and Print. In the Print dialogue box choose the "Selection" button under the Print range heading. Click OK to print.
There will be 38 panels which have been divided into five sessions at the conference. The panels are all listed below and there are links to all the paper abstracts from the panel listing.
Session 1: Monday 2nd September 2002, 15:45 - 17:00
| 1 | The EU and International Political Action: Past Experiences and Future Directions [Hunt Di Feliciantonio Samzelius] |
| 2 | The Evolving European Migration Law and Policy: Ambivalent Legacies and Challenges [Geddes Karyotis Kostakopoulou] |
| 3 | The Domestic Politics of Regionalism and European Integration (1) [Bourne Carl Palmer] |
| 4 | Institutional Reform: Nice and Beyond [Stark Vila Maior Tzortzis] |
| 5 | Security, Identity and Trust [Goodman Manners Tzankova Whitman] |
| 7 | Enlargement: Transition, Expectations and Capabilities [Georgiadis Haab Palánkai Stenberg] |
| 8 | Ideas and Norms in EU Policy-making [Heyne Rentzow Usui] |
Session 2: Tuesday 3rd September 2002, 11:00 - 12:30
| 9 | Security, NATO and the Baltic [Agius Archer Made Männik] |
| 10 | Parties (1) The End of the Democratic Deficit? Parliamentary and Party Solutions at Party Level [Day Speht Warleigh] |
| 11 | The Domestic Policies of Regionalism and European Integration (2) [Gunnarsson Hayward Konarski Laffan] |
| 12 | The European Commission: Leadership and Reform [Burns Cini Drake] |
| 13 | Citizenship and Equality [Bartle Papazoglu Selanec] |
| 14 | Dimensions of Policy-Making: Institutions and Processes of Europeanisation [Menz Pallis Rodokanakis Schelke Stevens] |
| 15 | Enlargement: International Law, EU Law and National Law [Bodiroga-Vukobrat Sleziakova Vadapalas] |
| 16 | EU External Trade Relations; Near and Far Abroad [Barnes I Fallon Jones A Knio] |
Session 3: Tuesday 3rd September 2002, 14:00 - 15:30
| 17 | Responses to European Integration: An Analysis of National Variations and Common Ground in Nordic EU Policy [Bergman Novack] |
| 18 | Parties (2) Exploring Developments in EU-level Parties: Policy Influence Despite the Voters [Bailey Benedetto Bindi Mosca] |
| 19 | Local, Regional and National Actors and Changing Patterns of Governance in the EU [Carter Deacon Gomez Royles] |
| 20 | Adjusting to the Europeanisation of Markets: Comparing Domain Dynamics [Lodge Thain] |
| 21 | Preparing for Enlargement: External and Internal Dimensions of Transition [Nowak Tomásek] |
| 22 | Single Market, Liberalisation and Deregulation [Barnes P Erdos Levy C Yeomans] |
| 23 | Enlargement and Security Issues in the Eastern Mediterranean I [Bicak Hearl Kivircik Piccoli] |
| 24 | Developing European Integration Theory [Manners Wivel] |
Session 4: Tuesday 3rd September 2002, 16:00 - 17:30
| 25 | EMU and the Macroeconomic Policy Mix [Ardy Hodson Maes Quaglia] |
| 26 | The Constitutional Convention and the 2004 IGC [Hoffmann Majcher Verges-Bausili] |
| 27 | French Relations with the European Union [Flood Milner Startin Usherwood] |
| 28 | Ireland and the European Union [Andréosso-O'Callaghan Holmes O'Brennan Rees] |
| 29 | Enlargement and Security Issues in the Eastern Mediterranean II [Kip Barnard Senyuva] |
| 30 | The EU, the US and Terrorism [Mowle Norman] |
| 31 | Interests, Parties and Politics: National and European Interactions [Binnema Fowler Murphy Perez-Solorzano Saurugger] |
| 32 | Small States and Enlargement [Blavoukos Jarukaitis Lee Tomova] |
Session 5: Wednesday 4th September 2002, 09:30 - 11:00
| 33 | Europeanising Interest Politics [Fairbrass Perez-Solorzano Redgrave Wilts] |
| 34 | Transnational Governance, Human Rights and Conditionality [Harmsen Holden Kennard Schwellnus Steffens] |
| 35 | The European Employment Strategy [Gore O'Hagan Threlfall] |
| 36 | Subnational Politics in a Multilevel Europe [Crowley Féron Giorgi] |
| 37 | Russia and the EU [Bykhovskiys Gower] |
| 39 | European Foreign Policy: Managing Successes and Failures [Bono Mawdsley Musu] |
Agius Andréosso-O'Callaghan Archer Ardy
Agius, Christine (University of Edinburgh)
Swedish Security Policy in the 21st Century: From
Neutrality to Non-alignment
The
end of the Cold War has seen a greater significance given to co-operative
dimensions of the security policies of Western democratic states. Sweden has
responded to this by actively supporting the creation of the EU’s crisis
management capacity, by engaging in NATO’s PfP Programme, and by making
important contributions to Baltic defence structures. Undeniably, this has given rise to a set of important
questions as to the embedded status of Swedish neutrality policy. Indeed, there
is empirical evidence to suggest that Swedish security policy is nowadays
defined in terms of non-alignment rather than neutrality. This paper seeks to
explore this claim by investigating Swedish involvement in European security. In
doing so it offers a critical analysis of recent shifts in the country’s
political discourse. In sum, the
paper holds that Swedish security policy has undergone a period of
normalisation, although political elites and the general public do not appear to
be ready for full NATO membership. In examining this issue, the paper will raise
a number of issues concerning the utility of orthodox international relations
theory. It will be argued that the
Swedish neutrality/non-alignment reflects distinctive, embedded domestic social
and political values.
Andréosso-O'Callaghan, Bernadette
(University of Limerick)
Enlargement
and Technological Change: New Challenges for Ireland
Recent developments in the area
of economic trade and growth theories suggest that the persistent wealth
differentials amongst countries are due to differences in knowledge. Knowledge
acquisition and human capital accumulation are the over-riding preoccupation of
countries eager either to catch up, or to sustain their competitive advance. In
particular, Ireland has won the reputation of the EU country par excellence that
has demonstrated an indisputable ability to import foreign capital and
knowledge, and to allow it to spill-over successfully into its economic fabric.
The ‘Irish developmental model’ is easily transposable to other countries of
Europe, and already some of the ingredients explaining the Irish economic
‘miracle’ have already been introduced in candidate countries.
Our contribution will briefly evoke these major ingredients, by highlighting the
importance of foreign (mostly American) capital and knowledge to Irish economic
growth over the past decade; it will then analyse the degree to which the
candidate countries represent a real challenge to Ireland in the years to come,
given:
(i)
the easiness with which the ‘Irish model’ can be transposed to other
(mostly small and open) European economies; in particular, the importance and
quality of human capital will be assessed;
(ii) the
changing economic and technological conditions in the world, and the quality of
MNE (multinational enterprises) plants in Ireland, suggesting that Ireland is in
fact a ‘slippery’ place for American investors (meaning that outflows of
capital from Ireland may increase with the rise in production and transport
costs in Ireland, and that the country lacks the knowledge expertise that would
make this investment ‘sticky’).
The article will conclude with an insight into the attempts at responding to
these challenges made by the Irish government so far, as well as with the
remaining policy implications.
Archer, Toby (Finnish Institute of International Affairs)
Finland and NATO: Mistrust and Misapprehension, Ethics
and Hypocrisy
Finland has abandoned any pretence of neutrality in its
international affairs, being an active EU member, including CFSP and ESDP.
Finnish troops have served under NATO command in SFOR and KFOR, and
Finland has been a leader in NATO’s PfP programme.
The traditional concept of mass, territorial defence is increasingly
being quietly ‘hollowed out’ as the Finnish defence forces change doctrine
towards small, highly trained, technologically advanced, deployable forces,
fundamentally designed for interoperability with other EU and western
militaries.
Nevertheless the official line of the government remains that Finland should not
abandon its position of military non-alignment and join NATO.
The population remains resolutely hostile to NATO, and many leading
politicians including the President and Foreign Minister share their suspicions.
This paper will argue that much of this Finnish mistrust is based on
misapprehensions of what NATO is and a slanted view of their country’s own
history. It will discuss in the
light of the NATO debate, the normative tensions apparent within Finland between
concepts of universal rights and the idea of state sovereignty and bounded
political communities. It will
explore the connections between security, national identity, ideas of self and
other, concepts of democracy and structures of states.
Ardy, Brian (South Bank University)
Cohesion and EMU
EMU
differs from other monetary unions because of the diversity of the countries and
regions to which it applies. This paper will analyse the impact of EMU on one
important aspect of this diversity, cohesion. The different facets of cohesion
such as income and unemployment are the focus of the paper’s first section.
Greater macroeconomic stability and lower interest rates should be major
benefits of EMU to cohesion countries. So the assessment of the impact of EMU on
cohesion, begins with a consideration of the possible effects on investment,
growth and employment of this macroeconomic stability. Then the effects of the
removal of the barriers to trade represented by uncertainty of exchange rates
and costs of currency exchange are examined. There are two related dimensions to
explore: first whether there will be further agglomeration of economic activity
at the EU’s core; second the effect of greater competition on economic
activity in the cohesion regions. The analysis will be extended from the short
to the long run by consideration of the effect of EMU on technology and
innovation. Since the EMU effect will vary among regions the paper will conclude
with an enumeration of the determinants of this regional differentiation.
Bailey Balli Barnes I Barnes P Bartle Benedetto Bergman Bicak Bindi Binnema Birley Blavoukos Bodiroga-Vukobrat Bono Bourne Brown Budden Burns Bykhovskiy
Bailey,
David (London School of Economics)
Explaining Social Democratic Party Policy in the
European Union
This paper aims to explain the policies
promoted by social democratic party policies inside the institutions of the
European Union. It argues that the
promotion of a liberal economic and social policy by social democratic parties
can be understood as a result of the shift to new social democracy at the
national level, combined with an attempt to pursue limited re-regulation of West
European capitalism in an attempt to maintain support at the domestic level from
traditional interests institutionalised within social democratic parties.
It is claimed, however, that in order for policies pursued at the EU-level
to be successful they must be compatible with the fragmented political authority
of the EU, itself legitimated by a neo-liberal discourse of competitiveness and
liberalisation. Paradoxically,
therefore, the promotion of traditional social democratic goals within the EU
actually assists in the process of limiting and dismantling the organisation and
collective power of the traditional social democratic interests it is designed
to represent. The validity of this
argument will be illustrated through an empirical analysis of the European
policies of the British Labour Party and the Party of European Socialists.
Balli, Volker (University College
Dublin)
Identifying the EU via Human Rights, Democracy and Cultural Diversity
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Barnes, Ian (University of
Lincoln)
EU Trade with China: An Assessment of
the Impact of China’s WTO Membership
It took just over 25 years for the EU and China to finalise their trading
arrangements in a way that satisfied membership criteria for the WTO. During
that time China moved from being a closed economy with essentially state run
industry to one that had embraces many features of capitalism and the market
economy. Effectively the accession of China to the WTO gave the EU a last
opportunity to legitimately press forward its trade agenda on a bilateral basis.
What emerged from the negotiations was that the EU was able to gain concessions
is areas where it was facing internal pressures such as agricultural surpluses
and textiles. Although all trade concessions gained by one specific member
within the WTO are to be shared by all, the negotiations followed a specific EU
agenda. However, many of the concessions are unlikely to have a desirable
impact:
1. They are unlikely to improve access to Chinese markets.
2. They will do little to promote transparency in Chinese
trade.
3.
The structural reform of the Chinese economy is unlikely to be enhanced.
The EU chose to gain concessions in
sectors where there has been least reform within the EU. That is, although the
membership of the WTO may enhance general reform of the Chinese economy, the
EU’s negotiations were pragmatically based upon opportunism rather than the
notion of partnership. Generally advantages gained in such circumstances tend to
be short-lived
Barnes,
Pamela
(University of Lincoln)
How National Ethical Stances on Nuclear Energy are Being Undermined
For the first time for many years, some member states are contemplating the
prospect of commissioning new nuclear power plants. This paper argues that
whilst nuclear energy is considered undesirable from an ethical perspective, the
openness of the European market makes its presence inevitable. Recent treaty
changes plus an enhanced appreciation of the true cost of decommissioning seemed
to reinforce the choice made by those countries that chose to eschew nuclear
power stations. However, as the market for electricity within the European Union
(EU) becomes more integrated the choice for those Member states and EU citizens
who desire the phase out of the use of the nuclear technologies everywhere is
disappearing.
Electricity consumption is increasing within the European Union and the level of
dependency of the EU on imported energy resources will rise to 70% by 2020 (CEC
2001). The beginning of the 21st century has been characterised by
rapidly fluctuating prices for alternative methods of energy production. The
assessment with respect to non-viability of nuclear generation was made during a
period of lower and more stable energy prices, especially for oil. Governments
were able to allow electorates to exercise their choice for a nuclear free
energy policy, as cheaper alternatives were available. This is no longer the
case. As costs of energy rise, the importance of the single market in
electricity has grown. The focus is now on the infrastructure to transfer that
electricity around the EU. Here is the dilemma of choice, how do you provide
nuclear free electricity for those who want it on the transmission lines and
electricity grids of the integrated market?
Bartle, Ian (University of Exeter)
The Europeanisation
of Utility Regulation. What is the Potential for ‘Market Citizenship’?
The Europeanisation of utility regulation has spawned European networks of
national regulators and industrial groups (e.g. in the telecommunications and
energy industries). The Commission often plays a leading role in these networks
and they appear to be an example of comitology which limits legitimacy and
citizenship in the EU. This paper examines these in the context of the
suggestions to improve democratic legitimacy raised in White Paper on Governance
and the debate on the future of the EU. Key suggestions for improvement include
more self regulation, ‘co-regulation’ and subsidiarity and a greater role
for public interests (e.g. environmental and consumer). Despite the attempts to
increase the role of public interests it is argued that the suggestions are
attempts to appease industry, national governments and regulators rather than to
properly address the lack of participation and legitimacy. Many key decisions
will still be left to opaque national regulators and industry groups with only
ad hoc and weak involvement of public interests. For the term ‘market
citizenship’ to have substance the Commission and national governments have to
be more proactive in incorporating public interests into the regulatory process
and high profile systems for citizen information and complaints procedures
should be established.
Benedetto,
Giacomo (London School of Economics)
Party Competition and Office Distribution in the
European Parliament, 1994-2002
The distribution of office is an area in which
party groups visibly compete and ally in the European Parliament. Politicians
achieve office not by campaigning for election in front of the public but by
forming alliances with other politicians. The paper assesses the way in which
the assignment of office has modified since 1994 and the enhancement of the
Parliament’s institutional powers following Maastricht and Amsterdam.
Ideological division has been caused by the exercise of new powers meaning that
competition for policy-related office has consequently intensified.
Bergman,
Annika
(University of Sussex)
Swedish and
Danish Attitudes Towards the Enlargement Process - A Case of Adjacent
Internationalism?
Sweden and Denmark have often
been defined as reluctant Europeans. Both states’
indecisiveness with regard to EMU membership, the Danish opt-outs from
the Maastricht Treaty as well as
general public scepticism have reinforced
this perception. Both Denmark and Sweden have, nevertheless, endorsed and
offered support to the imminent EU enlargement process, in particular Baltic
membership. While such engagement could be considered as a way of avoiding
further deepening of the Union this paper argues that it ? expression of
solidarity and commitment to the future of a stable and unified Europe.
This
paper seeks to develop further understanding as to the motives behind Danish and
Swedish enlargement policy. It does
so through a combination of conceptual inquiry and empirical evidence, drawing
up the foreign policy traditions of both states. More specifically, it seeks to
show that their support of Baltic EU membership could be conceived as a regional
expression of internationalism and small state solidarity.
Hence, the paper takes issue
with orthodox readings of the enlargement process by arguing for a non-realist
approach.
Bicak, Hasan Ali (Eastern Mediterranean University)
Compromises in Cyprus EU
Membership: Turkey and Others [joint paper with Mehmet Altinay]
Although Helsinki Council
Decision (1999) appears to have enabled the membership of Cyprus to the EU, even
if a solution could not be found to the Cyprus problem, efforts have been
intensified after the meetings of the two leaders, Mr. Denktas and Mr. Klerides
on 4th of December 2001. At the end of the first round of meetings,
although optimism is not as high as in the first day, hopes are still alive.
Turkey has been talking about the “simultaneous accession of Cyprus and Turkey
to the EU” and Mr. Denktas is stressing the need of a balance between Turkey
and Greece in case of a membership of Cyprus to the EU. Greece is to block the
enlargement if Cyprus is not accepted. Furthermore Greece would like to have the
Aegean issue to be solved before Turkey is offered a road map. This paper will
analyze each of these cases and will try to find out what sort of compromises is
likely to provide the best circumstances for a solution and a membership of
Cyprus to the EU.
Bindi, Federiga (University of Rome)
Voting Behaviour at the European and National Level: Is There a Correspondence?
A Comparitive Analysis of Italian, French, Spanish and Portuguese EPP'S Member
Parties [joint paper with Alessia Mosca]
The
Objective of the paper is to analyze the voting behavior of selected European
People Party’s member parties from Italy, France, Spain and Portugal - both in
the National and in the European Parliaments - on a number of European-related
issues, in the beginning of the 1990s and in 2000.
The
questions of research are:
A
- Are the domestic positions of national parties consistent with their European
families programs and views?
B - Is there a correspondence between parties’ voting behavior in the European
Parliament and in the national Parliaments?
The hypotheses are
that:
A
- There is no correspondence between parties voting behavior in the European
Parliament and in the national Parliaments because parties tend to vote
according to national agendas’ priorities.
B - Domestic positions of the national parties tend to be consistent with their
European families’s programs and views only and insofar as this presents a
“domestic” convenience for them:
The empirical
analisys will compare electoral manifestoes and programs for the national
elections with EPP electoral manifestoes for the European elections and EPP
Congresses documents: also, the voting behaviou of both MEPs and MPs will be
analized concerning the negotiations and ratification of TUE (1990-92) and the
negotiations and ratification of Amsterdam (1996-1997).
Binnema, Harmen
(Vrije
Universiteit)
European Integration and Changing Party Politics
This paper will examine to what extent political parties change due to the
development of the EU polity. Political
parties are considered vital for the working of a political system: they
aggregate interests, recruit candidates for office, provide ideologies and have
a linkage function between the public agenda and policy outcomes. They are
expected to be both responsive and accountable, and thus contribute to the
legitimacy of a political system. Increasing European integration - especially
over the last 15 years - leading to a situation of multi-level governance, might
affect political parties and lead to an erosion of these functions. I will focus
on two elements: programmatic change, as parties adapt to a new division of
responsibilities between the national and the European level, and effects on
accountability, as multi-level governance blurs "who is responsible for
what to whom".
Birley, Sue (University of
Reading)
Structural Funding in England and France: Are Some
Partners More Equal Than Others?
Unfortunately, this paper
has been withdrawn.
Blavoukos, Spyros
(University of
Essex)
Understanding Member-States’ Enlargement Policy-Making: The Case of Greece
The heavy bulk
of literature on enlargement concentrates primarily on the implications of
enlargement for the EU and/or the candidate countries with a relative lack of
attention to individual member-states. This paper looks at the case of Greece in
an attempt to understand the Greek enlargement policy from Copenhagen (1993) to
Helsinki (1999). It examines not only foreign policy considerations but also the
role of socio-economic pressure groups and the public opinion in the formation
of the Greek enlargement policy by making use of Robert Putnam’s ‘two-level
game’ theoretical framework. Analysis proceeds along the lines identified in
the framework, taking into consideration domestic policy-making institutional
structures, systemic features as well as the role of influential individuals in
the process. The main argument is that the congruence of foreign policy
considerations (Cyprus accession prospects; Balkan dimension; candidacy of
Turkey) and socio-economic ones (support by the economic establishment in view
of the emerging opportunities in the new markets) have led to a great degree of
homogeneity as regards the priorities in the enlargement policy. It is argued
that this homogeneity has been used to affect EU enlargement rhetoric and
decisions. However, the relatively personalised system of foreign policy-making
does allow space for individual interventions at the highest level and the turn
of the Greek position at Helsinki (1999) can be understood in this light as the
culmination of a ‘rapprochement’ effort initialised after the change of
leadership in the Greek Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
Bodiroga-Vukobrat,
Nada (University of Rijeka)
Legal Order in Transition
Countries and Adjustment According to European Law
All transition countries undergo three phases in their development from
authoritarian systems into stable democracies. The first phase is
“liberalism”, that is the opening of the system and the increased protection
of human rights.
The second, “democratization”, denotes the change of ruling forces. This
second phase ends with the implementation of the first democratic elections.
“Consolidation” as the third phase, is the test case whether the transitive
period develops into a democratic system. The implementation of the new social
system falls into the third phase. It depends on the framework of institutional
harmonization and is characterized by six features:
- General change; exchange of the whole order of society, economy, state;
replacement of the former ruling forces, emergence of a new elite and of new
political participants in the political process. Experts from the EU countries
have dealt with the implementation EC law into the legal systems of transition
countries.
The transition countries must adopt the ”acquis communautaire”. The success
of this adjustment process depends upon numerous internal and external factors
(political opportunity, economic advantages, market competition, advisory level
in the reform proceedings etc).
Bono, Giovanna
(University of Bradford)
Bridging the Accountability Gap in European Security
and Defence Policy (ESDP) [joint paper with Jocelyn Mawdsley]
In the paper we demonstrate that there is a clear accountability gap in the
emerging European Security and Defence Policy (ESDP). We argue that this is
partly due to the specific nature of ESDP and partly to broader domestic and
international political trends. We then examine the problem of democratic
accountability in ESDP by focusing on the lessons learnt from two policy-areas
covered by ESDP: the lessons drawn from EU/NATO Member States’ engagement in
peace-keeping/peace-enforcement operations (1994-2001) and lessons learnt from
co-operation in the armament sector.
The paper will then engage with some of the main proposals for reform that have
recently been discussed both in the EU Convention and in national/international
Assemblies for resolving the accountability gap in ESDP. We draw out the
implications of the EU reform debate for ESDP. We
will argue that, rather than opting for solution based on majoritarian rules,
the safeguarding of the comitology system and the strengthening of executive
power at the national and supranational levels, more imaginative solutions are
required that rely on strengthening best practice in parliamentary oversight and
reinvigorating civil society.
Bourne,
Angela (University of Dundeee)
European Integration and the Politics of Accommodation
in Nationally-Diverse Societies: The Case of the the Basque Country [joint paper with Rebecca Jones]
The
devolution of decision-making powers to minority nations has been the major
political instrument for the accommodation of national (ethno-cultural)
diversity in Western Europe. European integration has, in many cases,
accompanied devolution and this raises questions about the impact of the one on
the other. In this paper we explore the implications of European integration for
the accommodation of national difference within multi-national states by
analysing the institutionalisation of practices of 'shared sovereignty' in the
United Kingdom and Spain. The division of sovereignty between levels of
government at different territorial levels is a principle more familiar in
federal states than in regionalised unitary states like the UK and Spain.
However, it is possible to argue that European integration has provided a
context in which it is appropriate to consider whether the practices and
institutions of shared sovereignty developed in the EU's federal states have
been imported and institutionalised in regionalised states like Spain and the
UK. In the EU's federal states, the
encroachment of regional powers in the course of European integration has
produced a complex architecture of intergovernmental institutions and practices
which effectively create a system of shared sovereignty between regional and
central governments when it comes to the formation of the state's EU policies.
These arrangements allow regions to contribute as co-equal partners with those
of central authorities in the formation of the whole state's specific EU
policies. It is the question of
whether similar practices of shared sovereignty have developed in the UK and
Spain and their impact on the dynamics of conflict and co-operation between
nations in multi-national states that this research addresses.
Brown, David (University of Aberdeen)
Questioning the Contribution of the European Union in the Field of
Counter-terrorism: The Case of Northern Ireland
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Budden,
Philip (Cabinet Office)
Understanding the European Convention
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Burns, Charlotte
(University of Sheffield)
The European Commission
and Co-Decision: A Study of Declining Influence
The introduction of the co-decision procedure in 1993 led to a shift in the EU's
inter-institutional balance of power. A consensus has emerged that the
Commission was the loser, seeing its legislative influence reduced whilst the
European Parliament's power continued to grow. Yet there has been little
empirical work on how the Commission has sought to deal with its new status
under the co-decision procedure, or of how it behaves in conciliation. This
paper will seek to redress the imbalance in current academic work by presenting
empirical research on the novel foods regulation, a case where the Commission
sought to press its own agenda only to be excluded from meetings between the
Council and Parliament. The case will be taken as a departure point for
exploring the challenges faced by the Commission under co-decision as it seeks
to balance its gate-keeping prerogative with its role as a neutral arbiter. It
will be suggested that the Commission does still have the potential to exercise
informal agenda-setting power throughout the co-decision process but that it
will be most successful when it is genuinely seeking to find agreement between
the Council and Parliament, rather than trying to realise its own preferences.
Bykhovskiy,
Svyatoslav
(Russian Academy of Sciences)
EU
Eastern Enlargement and its Impact on Russia
Luxembourg (1997) and Helsinki (1999) Summits gave a new impetus to the
EU enlargement towards CEECs. The EU started accession negotiations with 12
applicant countries of CEE and Mediterranean. The integration process and the
enlargement of the EU will inevitably influence the interests of third
countries. Firstly, it concerns Russia which, being the largest European
country, now is outside the process and which has historical connections with
both the member states of the Union and the candidates for membership. In this
connection, the main concerns of Russia could be: tariffs and non-tariff
measures for Russian export to CEECs, transit of Russian goods through CEECs,
trade flows and investment which could change their direction from Russian
market to the CEECs, various problems of Kaliningrad region which will turn into
enclave after the enlargement. Among other concerns of Russia it could be
mentioned Common Agriculture Policy, EU Competition Policy, trans-border
cooperation etc. In the same time, Russia will deal with a stable and
predictable group of countries near its borders, which respect democratic values
and principles of free market. Instead of the great number of very different
bilateral agreements, it will develop relations with them within the single
legal framework - Partnership and Cooperation Agreement between Russia and the
EU. It is a proper time now to analyze in what way the PCA will be implemented
after the EU enlargement and what has to be done to adapt this agreement to the
new geopolitical and geoeconomic situation in Europe.
Carl Carter Christou Cini Crowley
Carl,
Jenny (University of Osnabrueck)
European Identity: Exploring Regional, National and
Supranational Identities with Reference to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland
The project deals with the question of whether there exists a European
identity, and with the relationship between the regions of Scotland, Wales and
Northern Ireland (and their respective collective identities) and the British
nation on the one hand, and Europe on the other. The aim is, eventually, to draw
conclusions as to whether it is possible to speak of a development of a deeper
regional identification with the EU / Europe.
The analysis is guided by notions that the nation state is losing its influence
in many of its ‘traditional’ spheres. Most importantly (for this study) this
concerns its power to define collective identities in a given territory. In this
context, European identity and the EU’s political system might offer new and
more opportunities for regions to redefine and express their identities.
The principal research questions are the following:
1) What relation is there between European integration and the development of
a European identity, and already existing cultural, political, regional,
national, and other identities, both theoretically, and empirically with regard
to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland?
2) More concretely, the question is whether Europe / the EU is becoming a new
framework, a new focus in the process of fabricating and forging (new)
identities by regional élites. Are there new regional pictures of Europe
emerging, what do they look like, and can they be traced within the political
discourse?
The work will be based on primary documents, which include, for example,
publications by political parties and movements, government white papers and
decrees, parliamentary debates. Moreover, the study is supported by theories of
collective identities and identification that allow the representations of
Europe / the EU within the public political discourse to be linked to collective
identities within the chosen regions.
Carter,
Caitriona (University of Edinburgh)
Sub-national
Governance and EU Policy Making in Member States [joint paper with
Martin Burch, Ricardo Gomez, Patricia Hogwood, Andrew Scott and Simon Bulmer]
A comparative study of the ways in which
regional
actors are drawn into and seek to influence policy making
on EU issues within member states. The paper will examine
practice in a number of EU member states and draw out
lessons for regional actors in the UK.
Christou,
George (University of Manchester)
The EU, Cyprus and Turkey: The Power of Attraction?
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Cini,
Michelle (University of Bristol)
Public
Service Ethics and the Reform of the European Commission
The
European Commission is in the throes of a reform process, which is proving to be
somewhat acrimonious and difficult to manage. While this process is in part a
consequence of the events surrounding the resignation of the Commission, it also
seeks to address some of the long-standing weaknesses which have plagued the
institution. Moreover, the reform has increasingly come to mirror other public
service reforms to the extent that one might argue that the White Paper of March
2000 was an attempt to inject and ethos of new public management into the
Commission.
Although
the reform project involves three main components: the management of priorities,
financial control and human resources, a fourth cross-cutting theme is
identifiable. This fourth theme engages with recent debates within the field of
public ethics and in a practical sense has involved the drafting of Codes of
Conduct and the injection of the language of 'standards in public life' within
the reform process. This paper examines this aspect of the Commission's reform
with an eye to the more general literature on public service ethics. It looks at
the steps already taken to improve ethical standards within the Commission and
how this relates to other aspects of the reform process. It asks if what we are
witnessing in the Commission is part of a much broader trend in public sector
reform, or simply a direct consequence of the criticisms thrown at the
Commission at the time of the famous resignation in 1999.
Crowley, John
(Fondation Nationale des Sciences Politiques)
Democracy in Europe: New Forms of Public Participation
at the Local Level [joint paper with Emmanuel
Brillet and Anne-Sophie Hardy]
Building
on the material collected in several suburban Paris districts, this paper will
study the forms of public participation at the local level. It will highlight
the tensions between the various dimensions of the local (neighbourhood, communal,
inter-communal) and the role of political parties in the dynamics of the local
democratic process. This paper will also focus on the implications for local
democracy of the growing trend in France towards amalgamation of communes
into inter-communal entities that are supposedly more efficient for a range
of planning purposes. Such groupings, which have been facilitated and reinforced
by recent legislation (to the point that they may be entered into without the
unanimous support of the communes
involved), have no mechanisms of direct democratic accountability. Amalgamation,
which often entails sharp shifts in the socio-demographic balance of the
relevant areas, tends to be deeply controversial. This paper will therefore seek
to analyze the consequences of discrepancies between political, administrative
and, socio-geographic, delineations of “locality”.
Day Deacon Di Feliciantonio Drake
Day, Stephen
(University of Manchester)
Democracy
Beyond the State: Assessing the Significance of Transnational Political Parties
in the European Union
Historically, representative
democracy has relied upon political parties within the boundaries of a
nation-state acting as the representative linkage or transmission belt between
the governing institutions and the citizens of the state. As the EU continues to
develop as a non-state polity, what sort of representative linkage is to be
transposed onto the European level? Are the little-known transnational political
parties capable of playing such a role?
This paper will evaluate the transnational parties (primarily the Party of
European Socialists – PES) in relation to their legal and constitutional
status as well as in terms of their real-world significance. It will ask, ‘if
they are to influence the formation of a European
demos,’ which remains one of the aspirational
aims of Article 191 of the EC Treaty, what sort of institutional and operational
changes are likely to be necessary to turn them into household names? This is
going to require evaluating the significance of:
1. On-going
legal and constitutional developments concerning Article 191 (including the
additional paragraph added at Nice) and the proposed Statute for European
Political Parties.
2. Examples
of initiatives at the grassroots level to enhance the profile of transnational
parties.
3.
The response of national state parties to these on-going processes of change.
Deacon, Russell (University
of Wales Institute, Cardiff)
The
Governance of Wales - The Welsh Office and the Policy
Process 1964-1999
The Welsh Office was in existence for
thirty-five years (1964-1999). As a devolved government department
it had the capacity to shape and alter a host of secondary
legislation that applied to Wales. It also had the
opportunity to develop other policy areas ranging from economic
development to tourism, education and agriculture. This
paper sets out to examine the extent to which unique Welsh
Office policy was created by the Welsh Office. The role
of the Welsh Secretaries are examined, these were often
controversial figures such as John Redwood and Ron Davies
who used the Welsh Office to stamp upon Wales their own
political or ideological visions. The paper also assesses
the impact of other factors on policy creation at the
Welsh Office and gives a brief summary of the effectiveness
of the devolved ministry upon policy making in
Wales in its thirty five years of operation.
Di Feliciantonio,
Susanna (Cambridge University)
Integrating European
Foreign Policy: Interests, Ideas and the Balkan Crises
This
paper examines
the relationship between the Balkan crises and the process of European foreign
and security integration, and argues that the Member States’ experiences in
the region over the past decade have had two critical effects on integration.
Firstly, the Balkan crises have exposed
the constraints of existing policies and instruments at the national - as well
as the European level - causing Member States to review their foreign policy
roles and redefine their strategic interests in a new security environment.
Secondly, this paper contends that the Balkan crises were necessary for
the emergence of a more effective European foreign policy. The shared
‘European’ experience with regards to these crises, has led to a greater
convergence of national foreign policy mechanisms and, more importantly, of the
ideas and interests underpinning national conceptions of foreign policy. Taking stimulus from the growing literature on the importance
of ideas in politics, which points to an alternative ‘ideational’ view of
the causality of European integration, this paper provides a systematic analysis
of how the ‘idea of Europe’ is increasingly seen as a ‘roadmap’ guiding
not only policies towards the Balkans, but influencing Member States’ views on
European integration.
Drake,
Helen (Loughborough University)
Where Is He Now? The Lessons and Life-cycles of a
Commission Presidency
Former
Commission President Jacques Delors (1985-1995) threw down a challenge to the
practice and theory of European integration by turning the Commission presidency
into a political position of apparent power, decisive influence, and deficient
legitimacy. How he did this – the combination of factors which transformed him
into ‘Mr Europe’, and the Commission into a semi-autonomous actor of
integration – is increasingly familiar to scholars of European integration.
Less obvious are the lessons of the Delors presidency for the political logics
of leadership in the EU. EU heads of state and government have failed on two
separate occasions between 1995 and 2000 to agree on a conceptual working model
for the Commission of the future; Delors’s successors, Jacques Santer and
Romano Prodi, have adopted contrasting political models of Commission
leadership; and Delors himself has sought to direct pro-Europeanism at home in
France. This paper seeks to review the Delors decade from the perspective of its
lessons for the modelling of the Commission’s future place in the twin
processes of European integration and domestic Europeanisation.
Eralp,
Atilla (Middle East Technical University)
Turkey in the Enlargement Process: From Luxembourg to
Helsinki
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Erdos,
Istvan (Eötvös Loránd University)
Implementation of e-Commerce Directive in Hungary
[to be tabled]
The theme of my conference paper and presentation shall be addressed to the
question of the legal aspects of electronic commerce, in particular to the issue
of the implementation of the e-commerce directive (Directive 2000/31/EC) into
the Hungarian legal regulatory environment. I am going to discuss the rules laid
down in the directive and compare them with the Hungarian Act on electronic
commerce adopted last autumn. The presentation shall consist of four parts.
Firstly, I shall talk about the legal aspects of e-commerce in general and the
importance of its regulation. Secondly, I shall give an international survey of
the legal regulation of electronic commerce. For example I will briefly examine
and by analysing compare the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce. Thirdly
I analyse the Directive in detail and compare in line with the Hungarian Act. As
a conclusion in the fourth part of my presentation I will try to draw some
inference on the Hungarian harmonisation on this issue regarding the accession
to the European Union
Fairbrass Fallon Féron Fitzpatrick Flood Fowler
Fairbrass, Jenny (University of
East Anglia)
The Europeanisation of Interest Groups: A Strategic
Decision-making Analysis
The
study of the European Union (EU), its policy processes and the role played by
various actors, has for many years been dominated by one variant or another of
the International Relations (IR) theory.
However, this debate had become rather sterile by the late 1980s.
In recent years, partly as a reaction against that stalemate, scholars
have began to research and theorise about the about the EU employing the concept
of Europeanisation. Rather than adopting the 'bottom-up' perspective associated
with IR theory, the Europeanisation framework examines the 'top-down' impact of
the EU on national political structures, processes and relationships.
This paper forms part of that movement by presenting and exploring
empirical evidence about the 'EU-effect' on national interest groups and their
interaction with national and supranational policy-makers. The surveyed groups
that provide the core of this paper belong to one of two policy areas:
environmental or industrial policy. Crucially, the paper offers a comparative
analysis along two dimensions. First, data concerning business interests in two
member states, firms and trade associations based in the UK and France, are
proffered and dissected. The second
axis takes the form of a cross-sectoral analysis, in which UK based business and
environmental interests are contrasted. Tools and ideas drawn from management
science are used to provide an analytic framework for exposing the causal
mechanisms in operation in the Europeanisation process in the UK and France in
relation to the interest groups.
Fallon,
Grahame (University College Northampton)
Exploring EU Attitudes Towards Russia’s Proposed Membership of the WTO
[joint paper with Alan Jones]
The paper will explore the degree of commitment to the Russian membership of the
WTO by the EU and its member states. The paper examines the extent to which the
EU has focused upon the long run implications of a Russian recovery based upon
the development of an effective basis for trade and production derived from WTO
membership. Notwithstanding the relatively short term predictions of Russian
membership within the next year to eighteen months, the paper argues that the
actual accession of Russia to the WTO will force a change in the way in which
Russia should be considered by the EU and some of its member states. It will
examine the implication of current questions of market access by Russia into
markets other than the obviously acceptable areas of primary production. It will
argue that the essential relationship will only vary as the domestic Russian
economy is increasingly forced to take account of the impact of the real world
economy upon its domestic production. The question remains, however, whether
existing circumstances in the EU Russian relationship will be changed
significantly at an economic level or whether WTO membership will simply change
the politics of EU Russia relations.
Féron, Elise
(Centre Interdisciplinaire de Recherches)
Euroregions as
Political Actors: The Cross-Channel Euroregion as a
Case Study
This
paper will explore the relationships between the Europeanisation process and the
regions. Though the EU was created exclusively by existing sovereign states, and
not by regional entities, since 1992 and the creation of an advisory Committee
of Regions, regions have become influential actors at the European level. This
paper will study the extent to which the creation of a “Euroregion”
(comprising Kent in England, the Nord – Pas-de-Calais region in France and the
three regions of Belgium) has an effect on the parameters of the local in this
part of Europe. The Euroregion, at present, is not a political entity, but an
economic grouping. Nonetheless, it seems to play a role in self-identification
in Northern France, and is the focus for specific policy issues. The paper will
therefore study both how the region itself works in political / policy terms,
and how its existence affects processes at lower territorial levels, with
particular emphasis on the Nord – Pas-de-Calais region of France.
Fitzpatrick,
Edmund (University of Lincoln)
The Compatibility of
the Court of Justice’s Recent Decision in Levi Strauss with the
Internal Market: Some Potential Shortcomings of Positive Integration
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Flood, Chris (University of
Surrey)
Euroscepticism:
A Problematic Concept
This
chapter addresses the theme of resistance to change by assessing the signficance
of Euroscepticism in France, taking account of public attitudes, the positions
of political parties, and the ideological positions developed by Eurosceptical
groups. Controversy over the current shape and future development of the EU is
promoted by a range of parties, or factions, pressure groups and think-tanks
with more or less hostile postures towards the institutions and processes
established at the EU level to date. Although outright Europhobia is confined to
a relatively small minority of the public, apathy and wariness are more
widespread. There is some demand for the representation of Eurosceptical
opinions, but interest is episodic, and the divisions between and within
Eurosceptical groupings limit their effectiveness. Moreover, Euroscepticism
faces the momentum of change as state power drains upwards to the European
level, and potentially to global level, and downwards to subnational level,
regardless of the question of where sovereignty lies; Eurosceptics have to chase
a moving target. As the cases of Britain and Denmark show, however, it is not
impossible for the weight of Eurosceptical opinion to function as a real
constraint on government policy, and potentially on the operation of the EU
itself, and so Eurosceptical political groups in France do have something to
play for.
Fowler,
Brigid (University of Birmingham)
Candidate State Party Politics and the EU Accession Process:
Can They Make a Difference?
This paper identifies ways in which candidate
state political parties and party systems may make a difference to their
countries’ EU accession processes. It thus opens a new field in the study of
EU enlargement. Such comparative and theoretical work as exists on enlargement
mostly focuses on the EU. The negotiation of EU accession is now an experience
shared by 21 states, but we have little systematic knowledge about the political
structures and strategies in candidate states that may help explain differences
between their accession processes. This is particularly the case with regard to
accession negotiations, which are not considered in current work on the impact
of accession conditionality. Emerging literature on candidate state party
attitudes to the EU is similarly only weakly integrated with explanations of
accession outcomes, failing so far to treat parties as government actors.
The paper considers the current accession process as having two main components:
the meeting of accession conditions, and the achievement of a ratified accession
treaty. Against this background, the paper derives hypotheses about the possible
impact of candidate state parties and party systems from existing literatures -
on the role of parties in domestic politics and policy outputs, and on theories
of international negotiation, particularly Putnam’s notion of a ‘two-level
game’. The paper suggests that the beliefs of governing parties, the strength
of their political position and the domestic resources at their disposal may
help to explain outcomes in their state’s accession process.
Geddes Gegout Georgiadis Giorgi Gomez Goodman Gore Gunnarsson
Geddes,
Andrew (University of Liverpool)
The Spatial and
Temporal Reconstruction of Migration as a Challenge to European
Governance
This
paper analyses the Europeanisation of migration as a challenge to European
governance. First, the paper will examine the spatial and temporal
reconstruction of migration policy. The spatial aspect refers to the
establishment of EU level co-operation and integration with a strong security
focus within which national executives have been particularly active
participants since at least the mid-1980s. The temporal dimension refers to the
more recent attempts to reconstruct at a temporal distance, labour recruitment
policies to fill labour market gaps in key sectors (the ICT sector is a good
example). Taken together these allow the identification of four questions, which
are assessed by the paper: the development of EU migration policy competencies
linked to forms of power and authority distinct from the national with scope for
supranationalisation of policy and associated processes. The asymmetrical
effects of Europeanisation as illustrated by the effects of migration policy
development on newer immigration countries in southern, central and eastern
Europe. The implementation dilemmas linked to the development of a Community
migration policy. The 'spillover' between migration and linked issues such as
welfare state organisation and social rights.
Gegout,
Catherine (European University Institute)
The Lifting of the European Union's Flight Ban and the
Reinforcement of its Financial Sanctions Against the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia (early 2000): The Role of the US and the Locking-in Effect of the
Institutions
Unfortunately, this paper
has been withdrawn.
Georgiadis,
George (Cambridge University)
Bridging Post-communist Transition and EU Enlargement:
In Search of Causality
This paper will try to bridge two branches of literature which so far have
developed in parallel routes. The focus of the first branch, which deals with
the eastward enlargement of the EU, has been biased towards the implications of
the accession of candidate post-communist countries on the institutions and
existing members of the European Union. The second branch of literature deals
with the transformation of post-communist states as a domestic phenomenon,
ignoring the dynamic effects of European integration in the process. As this
paper will argue, to explain the transformation patterns of post-communist
countries, it is essential to take under consideration the desire of the EU to
enlarge. By so doing the paper will challenge the established notion that
pressure from transition countries ‘forced’ the EU to enlarge. Finally,
since establishing causality is central to any form of explanation, and to
provide an alternative account, this paper will test the assumption of an EU-induced
transformation against quantitative measures of transition.
Giorgi, Liana
(Interdisciplinary Center for Comparative Research)
Mobilisation and Alliances in the Trans-Alpine
Region
Building on the material collected in the
course of other projects dealing with the trans-Alpine region, this paper will
examine the mobilisation in the Tyrol region against transit traffic and for
stricter thresholds for environmental protection. The trans-Alpine region could
be described as a Euroregion whereby the borders are variably conceived of as
either opportunities (as in the case of the Lyon-Turin axis for France and Italy
where there is also an active European economic grouping) or as barriers (as in
the case of the Brenner crossing between Austria and Italy). Subsequently, the
problems posed by trans-Alpine traffic are perceived at one and the same time
(yet variably by different actors) as local problems seeking a European solution
or as European problems seeking local solutions. The upcoming end of the
eco-point system for regulating transit traffic through the Austrian Alpine
route is expected to once again heat the debate within Austria but also in the
neighbouring countries. The purpose of this case study will be to study the
alliances that emerge and how these differ from those of the mid-nineties.
Gomez,
Ricardo (University of Manchester)
Sub-national
Governance and EU Policy Making in Member States [joint paper with
Martin Burch, Caitriona Carter, Patricia Hogwood, Andrew Scott and Simon Bulmer]
A comparative study of the ways in which
regional
actors are drawn into and seek to influence policy making
on EU issues within member states. The paper will examine
practice in a number of EU member states and draw out
lessons for regional actors in the UK.
Goodman,
Clorinda (University of Bristol)
European Integration and Social Capital
The importance of social, as well as economic, cohesion has been highlighted
recently, as well as an increased need for ‘solidarity’. These concepts are
closely related to social capital and trust. Regional disparities have been
addresses by various EU programmes, including Europartenariat, which aimed to
help small businesses make cross-border collaborative links.
The evaluation of such programmes, and of cohesion levels, has often been by
comparison of statistical data, ignoring qualitative issues such as social
capital or trust generated at a transnational level. Social capital has been
identified as a crucial for economic success and for healthy and successful
democracies. Trust has been described as a sense of shared ‘identity’ in the
context of working together.
This paper will present the results of a study of Europartenariat delegates from
UK, Ireland, Germany and Spain, gathered from a survey and interviews about
their sense of shared identity and mutual trust, both amongst themselves
(‘lateral’ trust), and between them and the EU institutions (‘vertical’
trust).
Whilst lacking Putnam’s longitudinal perspective, the study aims to contribute
to the debate on cohesion by evaluating outcomes from an EU programme and cross
border contact amongst the SME sector in a more qualitative way.
Gore, Tony
(Sheffield Hallam University)
Uneasy Travelling Companions: Mainstreaming the
European Employment Strategy in European Regional policy Programmes
Policy-making and implementation in the European Union (EU)
has increasingly become complex and multi-faceted, with the pursuit of the same
substantive objectives involving different pathways and modes of delivery. This
is especially the case with the new “open method of policy co-ordination”
adopted at the Lisbon summit of the Council of Ministers in December 2000. In
fact, this approach has been used in the design and implementation of the
European Employment Strategy (EES) since its launch in 1997.
This seeks to co-ordinate existing labour market policies of member
states within an overarching framework of guidelines and targets. As such, it
recognises the need for a high degree of flexibility in response to geographical
variations in the European labour market, while at the same time ensuring that
the interventions of individual countries are contributing to the achievement of
common EU employment aims. Recognition of the importance of more concerted
action in certain regions instantly brings the EES into the long-standing sphere
of European regional policy; since the mid-1970s this has acted as the main
vehicle at EU level in combating unemployment and economic decline in the
“lagging regions”. Moreover, the lack of a dedicated expenditure stream for
the EES has also meant that those responsible for its implementation have turned
to the Structural Funds as an additional way in which its employment goals might
be achieved. In other words, policy co-ordination in relation to the EES
involves not just exerting influence over the direction and content of national
policies, but also integrating or “mainstreaming” it into Structural Fund
programmes.
This paper is a critical exploration of the issues raised by this approach. In
particular, it will examine the nature of this “mainstreaming” relationship
in terms of the structures and mechanisms put in place to achieve it in the
context of the current Objective 1 programmes operating in the UK. It will do
this by reference to the vertical and horizontal linkages between European,
national and regional levels, and by assessing the extent to which strategic
frameworks, programme guidance and programme content have successfully
integrated EES considerations. The paper will conclude by reviewing the
implications of its findings for theories of European governance and
institutional relationships.
Gunnarsson, Jan (University
of Copenhagen)
Communication Links Between Public and Private
Interests and the Europeanisation at the Regional Level
This
paper tries to shed light on the way in which sovereignty may be transferred
from the state to the sub-national level as a result of European integration. It
is flavoured with empirical evidence of cross-border cooperation in the Southern
Baltic region (the Greater Copenhagen area and Scania in Southern Sweden).
The paper poses the question whether communication links between public
organizations and private companies could improve the 'bottom up' drive from the
regional level in multi-level governance and thereby improve the legitimacy of
the EU. The paper looks into this question by considering crucial differences
between Denmark and Sweden with regard to institutions in domestic politics.
Empirically, the paper investigates policies pursued by regional authorities
with respect to public services to private companies and how these policies
affiliate with the overall policies of EU-focused regional associations.
Theoretically, it is argued that the establishment of a regional role in the EU
can be explained by an approach based on evolutionary theory of institutional
change. The notion of 'output-based legitimacy' is applied to clarify the
legitimising force of political actions channelled through industrial networks.
Haab Haglund Harmsen Hayward Hearl Heyne Hodson Hoffmann Holden Holmes Hunt
Haab, Mare
(Estonian European Union Information Secretariat)
Communication, Mediation, Political Involvement - EU
Enlargement and the Challenges of EU Information Policy of a Small Applicant
Country
Communicating EU enlargement is an area of
increasing importance. It is an issue of significance and concern in those
states who aim at re-establishing their place in the Old World and for those who
have already joined the “Club”. Estonia is an interesting case representing
“living proof” of a possibility to transform within a decade its political
and economic systems to match the ones characteristic of democratic,
market-oriented Western States. Surprisingly, it is also the country’s public
opinion regarding the European Union issues that seems to match the one of the
existing member-states rather than the majority of other applicant countries.
However, at the verge of the new wave(s) of EU enlargement, this phenomenon
could provide for definite concerns. Why would a small nation of 1,3 million,
who has after 50 years of occupation re-established its independent statehood in
1991, be so modest in its public support to the European Union which no doubt
provides a clear form for marking the peripheral European country with a strong
western identity? What could be the reasons for the paradox that the majority of
the Estonians consider joining the EU beneficial for themselves, yet, do not
support this by large? Is it a collective, nation-wide stupidity that has struck
not only the one country? Or are
there other reasons why in Estonia, likewise in many member-states, the opinion
polls show so far 58% support to EU at its best.
The paper addresses the issues related to the multi-dimensional process of EU
information and communication policy of a small state and young statehood from
the perspective of the Government.
Haglund,
Anne (University of Hull)
Nordic Presidencies and the European Union's Northern
Dimension
Unfortunately, this paper
has been withdrawn.
Harmsen,
Robert (Queen's University Belfast)
The OSCE and the European Human Rights Regime
While the proclamation of the 'Charter of Paris' in 1990 appeared to herald both
the beginning of a 'new European order' and the centrality of the then
Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe (CSCE) within that order,
events in the ensuing years have not borne out this initial, (over) ambitious
vision for the institutional architecture of the continent.
Against the background of this more general institutional trajectory,
this paper explores the relative 'successes' and 'failures' of the Organisation
for Security and Co-operation in Europe in the field of human rights.
On the positive side of the balance sheet, both the High Commissioner on
National Minorities (HCNM) and the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human
Rights (ODIHR) appear to have carved out a distinctive niche within the broader
framework of the European human rights regime.
Yet, conversely, attempts at creating a functional interstate 'human
dimension mechanism' appear to have floundered. More generally, beyond the 'human dimension' stricto sensu, the OSCE Court on Conciliation and Arbitration has
yet to hear a case. Underlying this
pattern of 'successes' and 'failures', it is argued that one may see the more
general emergence of a pan-European human rights regime on the basis of a
patchwork of institutional solutions which, in themselves, pose new problems
concerned with the need to ensure complementarity between the major players (EU,
Council of Europe, and OSCE) in the field.
Hayward,
Katy (University College Dublin)
The Region Between State and Nation: Contested
Definitions of Northern Ireland in the European Context
This paper investigates the role of regionalism in the European Union with
regard to a parallel reworking of the concept of the nation-state. The process
of European integration has stimulated change both ‘above and below’ the
nation-state, reflecting an active paradox within the European Union: on the one
hand, the transcendence of territorial boundaries and, on the other, the
continued importance of territorial locality for political representation and
identity. This paradox is encapsulated in the application of regionalism in
attempts to facilitate cross-border cooperation as well as accommodating
internal diversity. At a national level, governments have been able to present
European integration in general and regionalism in particular to assert the
continued integrity and centrality of the nation-state.
This
paper explores this thesis through examining the utilisation of regionalism in
the United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland, whose different approaches to
European integration and regionalism were integrally related to their conception
of the ‘contested territory’ of
Northern Ireland. Devolution in the United Kingdom may be seen as the British
government’s use of regional representation to pre-empt nationalist demands
or, in the case of Northern Ireland, to diffuse nationalist tensions. In
contrast, the Republic of Ireland has been reluctant to divide the country into
regions and has instead preferred to identify the island of Ireland as a
‘region of Europe’. The Good Friday Agreement (1998) applied the EU model of
cross-border cooperation, multilevel representation and multilayered citizenship
in finding an ‘agreed solution’ between transcending territorial boundaries
and recognising diverse territorial identities. Thus, although the process of
European integration could not raise Northern Ireland onto a new post-national
political plane, it enabled the national discourse and regional politics of
Britain and Ireland to adapt to the reconfiguration of the political
significance of territory and identity.
Hearl,
Derek (Eastern Mediterranean University)
Cyprus: A New Kind of member State? [joint
paper with Wojciech Forysinski]
After nearly 40 years of deadlock, at the time of writing (February 2002), the
Cyprus Problem looks closer to a solution than ever before. The leaders of the
two sides are currently engaged in intensive talks amid widespread speculation
that solutions both to the Island's internal governance problem and its putative
EU Membership will be found by the summer of this year. Although the talks are
at present shrouded in secrecy there are indications that what may be under
discussion is a unique mix of federal, confederal and consociational elements
defying traditional academic classification. This paper will analyse the
situation as it appears by the time of the 2002 Conference in the light of
recent direct and indirect pressures from the EU and certain of its member
states. It will ask and seek to
answer the question as to whether the prospect of imminent EU Membership has
after all acted as the "catalyst" it was supposed to be - albeit more
as a stick and less of the carrot originally envisaged. Finally, it will
conclude by considering emerging models for the Island's potential
future constitutional relationship with the rest of the EU.
Heyne,
Anja (University of Bristol)
What Determined the Structural Arrangements of European
Monetary Union, 1990-1999
The structure of EMU has been determined by the Maastricht Treaty and the
Stability and Growth Pact, both of which are characterised by their distinct
monetarist outlook. The aim of this paper is to explain why EMU took the form it
did by considering the importance of monetarist ideas in its establishment. This
paper proposes that an epistemic community, consisting of monetarist experts,
was influential in shaping the Maastricht Treaty and the Stability and Growth
Pact, although Keynesian economists fiercely opposed monetarist policy
proposals. In order to test this hypothesis, this paper develops a theoretical
framework, that builds on Peter Haas's concept of epistemic communities, to
analyse how a group of monetarist economists might have influenced
policy-making, what conditions might have facilitated this process and why
monetarist experts might have been able to shape the institutional arrangements
underpinning EMU at the expense
of other possible proposals.
Hodson, Dermot (London School of Economics)
The Role of Consensus in the Monetary and Fiscal Policy Mix
Fiscal
policy within the euro zone remains by and large a matter for national
governments. To the extent that
these member states share the same interest rate, fiscal policy represents a
matter of common concern. This concern is expressed through the Stability and Growth
Pact, which prevents excessive deficits and promotes a medium term fiscal
position of close to balance or in surplus. Providing that it operates as advertised, the pact should ensure that the
fiscal policies of any one member state threaten neither the stability of its
peers or the objectives of the European Central Bank.
In its present form, however, there is little that the pact can do to
guarantee a harmonious monetary and fiscal policy, not least in the face of
disagreement between national policy makers over the appropriate course of
action. This paper investigates whether such consensus can be promoted through
existing soft law policy instruments, such as the Broad Economic Policy
Guidelines, or whether further institutional developments are necessary in this
regard.
Hoffmann,
Lars (Federal Trust)
The
European Convention: An Intersection of Law, Politics and the Ordinary Citizens
The paper examine whether
the Constitutional Convention which has been invoked by the Laeken summit in
December 2002, can be considered a legitimate constitutionalisation procedure.
The
‘legitimacy deficit’ of the EU has
been well covered in other literatures (see in particular, Beetham and Lord Legitimacy
in the European Union). Today’s discussion about a future European
constitution is partly a consequence of this deficit. But can the procedure,
that resulted from the Laeken summit in December 2001, be considered as
legitimate itself? What should the process of enactment of a EU constitution be
like in order to be considered legitimate?
Various
intergovernmental and neofunctional accounts
of legitimacy in the EU will be critically examined.
The findings will then be used as a comparative basis. Key aspects of the
Constitutional Convention will henceforth be measured against these results: The
composition of the Convention, the way the composition has taken place the
working procedure of the Convention generally and the presidium in particular as
well as the rules of procedure which have been assigned to it. Also, the issues
the Convention is dealing with (and eventual results) shall be critically
assessed and put into the perspective of legitimacy.
Holden,
Patrick (University of Limerick)
Aid,
Conditionality and the EU’s Strategy in the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership
This
paper offers a critique of certain instruments used by the EU to direct the
course of the evolving Euro Mediterranean Partnership (EMP). The EMP involves
several different forms of conditionality in support of a variety of EU
objectives, which include economic liberalization and support for democracy/
human rights.
Aid is one form of conditionality in that allocations are intended to be
flexible and reward partners pursuing ‘positive’ policies. Apart from being
an instrument of conditionality however, aid is a form of
‘bottom up’ intervention in the political and economic structures of
the partner states. Thus it is intended to complement the top down impact of
conditionality in the pursuit of the objectives cited above. In practice both
forms of intervention have been directed mainly towards the economic rather than
the political sphere. Apart from this lopsidedness there is a general consensus
that aid policy has not been especially effective in promoting the EU’s goals.
One explanation for this state of affairs can be found in a lack of capacity on
the EU’s part to use aid instruments effectively and a certain lack of clarity
in its objectives.
Holmes,
Michael (Liverpool Hope University College)
The Development of Opposition to the EU in Ireland
The rejection of the Treaty of Nice in Ireland in 2001 shed
new light on the opposition to the EU in the country. This paper seeks to
evaluate the main opposition groups involved in the Nice campaign; political
parties like the Greens, Sinn Féin and various left-wing groups, and pressure
groups ranging from the Peace and Neutrality Alliance to Youth Defence. It looks
at the history of their involvement in the five EU-related referendums that have
been held in Ireland and analyses the main criticisms they voice of the EU. On
this basis, the paper will identify the different motivations behind opposition
to the EU in Ireland, and will argue that while some groups are opposed to the
very idea of European cooperation, others express far more nuanced criticisms of
the Union. These differences offer the prospect of a way around the current
impasse in Irish-EU relations. The paper will be based on a series of interviews
with key individuals from the main opposition groups involved in the Nice
campaign.
Hunt, Lisa
(Loughborough University)
The European Union and the Former Yugoslavia: The Development of a European
Foreign Policy?
The case of the EC/EU’s variable involvement in the various phases of
Yugoslavia’s violent demise provides a sustained example of the fluctuations
in EU-level foreign policy co-operation over a decade.
Conceiving of EU foreign policy as a system engaged in a dynamic relationship
with its operational environment, the focus of this paper will specifically be
the contested notion of a discernible EU-level foreign policy (European Foreign
Policy). The course and extent of any change in the nature of that policy will
be examined through a systematic examination of the externally directed output
of the Union’s single institutional framework vis a vis the former Yugoslavia.
Five phases of EC/EU activity will be considered corresponding to the conflicts
in Slovenia/Croatia, Bosnia, Kosova and Macedonia.
The course of policy development will be discussed in terms of the extent to
which patterns of output amount to what can be described as a foreign policy.
This is foreign policy as traditionally understood but more importantly also in
terms of the evident emergence of a new and distinct type of international actor
that demands a more inclusive understanding of what constitutes foreign policy
and the type of actor that can have one.
Jarukaitis,
Irmantas (University of Vilnius)
Constitutional Basis of Lithuania's Accession to the EU
Fastening pace of negotiations concerning Lithuania’s accession to the EU and
its course shows that Lithuania’s membership in the EU materialises little by
little. Of course, this issue rises complex questions in all spheres of life:
economic, social, cultural, legal, etc. However, if to look from the legal point
of view, one of the fundamental questions would be constitutional basis of
Lithuania’s accession to the EU, or put it in more simplistic way, whether the
Lithuanian Constitution “allows” the Lithuania’s membership in the EU?
Although the Constitution contains the provisions concerning Lithuania’s
participation in the traditional international organisations, it is apparent
that the EU is not of that kind. It’s important, that the answer to this
question heavily depends on the answer, how the EU will look in the future.
Provisions of the Treaty of Nice and the Laeken Declaration show that still
there are no clear answers to this question. If to look at the current state of
development of the EU, it may be argued that the Constitutional amendments which
would provide for transfer of part of state institutions competence to the EU
institutions, direct effect and supremacy of the EU law should be adopted in
order to create proper constitutional basis of the accession. On the other hand,
the Laeken Declaration forces to think, how possible changes of the EU itself
would affect Lithuania’s constitutional basis. It’s hard to find the answer
to this question in the Laeken Declaration, because its content is ambiguous in
that respect. One may say that by this the new direction was set towards even
more close co-operation between the Member States, whatever forms and names it
will take. It seems that the constitutional structure of the EU will remain the
product of the permanent constitutional development, therefore it’s rather
hard to predict, what influence it would have to Lithuania’s constitution. At
the same time it is clear, that if proper constitutional basis for Lithuania’s
membership in the EU are in place and Lithuania becomes the Member State, it
would have the right to participate in the further EU development and influence
its future.
Jones, Alan
(University College Northampton)
Exploring EU Attitudes Towards Russia’s Proposed Membership of the WTO [joint
paper with Grahame Fallon]
The paper will explore the degree of commitment to the Russian membership of the
WTO by the EU and its member states. The paper examines the extent to which the
EU has focused upon the long run implications of a Russian recovery based upon
the development of an effective basis for trade and production derived from WTO
membership. Notwithstanding the relatively short term predictions of Russian
membership within the next year to eighteen months, the paper argues that the
actual accession of Russia to the WTO will force a change in the way in which
Russia should be considered by the EU and some of its member states. It will
examine the implication of current questions of market access by Russia into
markets other than the obviously acceptable areas of primary production. It will
argue that the essential relationship will only vary as the domestic Russian
economy is increasingly forced to take account of the impact of the real world
economy upon its domestic production. The question remains, however, whether
existing circumstances in the EU Russian relationship will be changed
significantly at an economic level or whether WTO membership will simply change
the politics of EU Russia relations.
Kahraman Kale Karyotis Kaveshnikov Kennard Kip Kivircik Knio Konarski Kostakopoulou
Kahraman,
Sevilay (Middle East Technical University)
The Integration of Turkey into the CFSP Pillar
Unfortunately, this paper
has been withdrawn.
Kale,
Basak (Middle East Technical University)
The Consequences of Turkish Accession to the European
Union on the Aspects of Immigration and Asylum Policies
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Karyotis,
George (University of Edinburgh)
European Immigration Policy in the Aftermath of
September 11: Reinvigorating the Securitisation Discourse
Abstract not provided
Kaveshnikov,
Nikolay (Russian Academy of Science)
Dividing lines in Europe: Real and Imaginary
Unfortunately, this paper has been
withdrawn.
Kennard, Ann (University of the West of England)
Border Regions as Agents of Change in Central and Eastern Europe
The border regions of central and eastern Europe have undergone rapid and
far-reaching change since 1989. From a ‘simple’ situation where the only border with any
real practical significance was the East-West divide, a patchwork of contrasting
interfaces has now emerged. Each
has its different meaning, determined by changing historical, cultural and other
relationships, and in most cases by its own physical displacement due to
competing territorial claims.
The institutionalisation of these borders has had the effect of thrusting them
into the limelight in ways which were unforeseen, and with both positive and
negative effects. The varying speeds at which the different central and east
European countries are achieving their goal of joining western organisations
means that there are tensions on some borders (cf.Schengen) alongside attempts
at a new cooperative approach. The paper will attempt to show how and why borders and their
adjacent regions are in the vanguard of change, juxtaposed as they are between
new national priorities and externally imposed agendas.
To what extent is the ‘socio-spatial consciousness’ (Paasi) in these
border regions changed by these agendas and will security issues inhibit the
establishment of a post-modern approach?
Kip
Barnard, Fulya (Middle East Technical University)
The Formation of EU's Internal Security Framework and
its Implications on Turkey
The
proposed paper aims to analyse the EU's internal security framework and its
effects on EU- Turkish relations and Turkey's possible accession to the EU.
Analysing the acceptance of Turkey's candidacy by the EU, many of critical
issues in respect of future EU-Turkish relations relate to the security concerns
of the EU and particularly Turkey's internal security.
The EU accepted Turkey as a candidate for EU accession in December 1999. In
November 2000 the EU outlined the issues that Turkey must address before
entering into formal negotiations, including guaranteeing minority rights,
reducing the role of the military in politics and supporting a solution to the
Cyprus problem. Turkey's internal problems including widespread corruption,
smuggling and terrorism pose an internal security threat to the EU. Finally
Turkey is a major transit country country for illegal immigrants and smuggling
and this is also of concern for the EU. Turkey's candidacy in EU is a very hot
issue in Turkey. The key areas of concern in Turkeys candidacy are soft security
issues, such as migration, ethnic and religious unrest and the human rights. The
international security aspects have been discussed widely in Turkish academic
circles. However, these internal issues have not been approached with an
international relations perspective. This paper aims at bringing a new outlook
to the security aspect of Turkey- EU relations.
Kivircik,
Elif (Marmara University)
Turkey in the EU Accession Process: The Contribution of
Turkey's Participation to the EU
In
the context of the Turkish candidacy for full membership to the EU, one of the
most important facts generally overlooked is the potential contribution of
Turkey in different ways to the EU's future especially in the current
restructuring of the world system. In the paper, this subject which can also be
expressed as 'the cost to the EU upon the non-integration of Turkey' will be
discussed in the highlight of geo-strategic, economic and political components.
Hence, the paper is in the aim of a help in re-evaluation of Turkey's existence
in the enlargement process despite her inconveniences and it will allow a
comparison between what European Union needs and what Turkey offers...
Knio,
Karim (University of Birmingham)
The EU's Mediterranean Policy: Do All Roads Lead to
Barcelona?
The
twentieth century was marked by the rise of regional trade blocs. The European
–Mediterranean Partnership, which aims to create a free trade area in this
geographical zone by the year 2010, constitutes a recent example of this global
phenomena. It is an attempt by the EU to reinvigorate its Mediterranean policy
and deal with its southern flank with a new approach based on developing and
ameliorating the economic setting of these under performing economies as a long
term step towards propelling political and social stability in the region. The
EU has endorsed a Neo Liberal perspective in economic development by trying to
introduce to these economies the magic of free capital markets, trade
liberalisation, privatisation, deregulation and foreign direct investment.
Nevertheless, a growing literature in political economy refutes the foundations
of this particular policy. It outlines the negative implications of the economic
transition process on these respective economies. Accordingly, this paper will
try to sketch an overview of the economic provisions contained in the European
Mediterranean partnership by highlighting the benefit and the cost dimensions of
these agreements. The paper will conclude that the EU’s Neo Liberal
developmental policy in the Mediterranean will not bring about the intended
prosperity; the logic of the free market will only widen income disparities and
destabilise the socio-economic equilibrium. In this ambit, the paper suggests a
different developmentalist approach based on a corporatist mode of governance
that seems to be a more viable engine of genuine economic development.
Konarski,
Wawryzniec (Warsaw University)
Regionalistic Movements as the Current Form of
Nationalism in Contemporary
Europe and their Possible Influence on the Idea of United Europe [to
be tabled]
In last decades the
term regionalism became the key word for the processes which were developing
simultaneously with the European integration. Both terms remain in mutual
dependence and have an impact on the nation-state in its classic, i.e. post
(French) revolutionary understanding. The political integration generates the
tendency towards political differentiation of regions, which in this way may be
encouraged to escalate their - already manifested - cultural, economic, and
political demands. It finally leads to weakening of a nation-state. Despite the
fact that regionalism - depending on the local specific - may adopt several
meanings, for the purpose of this paper it is perceived in two, although
interdependent ways. Firstly, as the nationalism of small nations (and/or
national minorities) forced to strengthen their existence while remaining under
pressure from large nations which dominate in currently existing nation-states,
it is called a regionalistic movement. And secondly, as the form of spatial
distribution of power on different levels of the political system in the
nation-state it becomes a process of regionalization. In other words (ethno)
regionalistic movements appear as a small nations’ reply on the above quoted
large nations’ pressure, whereas the regionalization is an offer from the
latter towards the above movements’ demands. It seems to be worthwhile to
notice that this offer is stimulated, although not initiated by the European
integration’s process. Finally